
Short answer: in most cases, yes. If you've just had a Fire Door survey come back with faults flagged, it can feel like the only safe answer is to rip the door out and start again. That's rarely true. Most faults we find on a Fire Door survey are repairable. The real risk sits elsewhere: a repair that isn't done within the door's certified scope can fail the very next inspection, even if it looks fine to the eye and closes the way it always has.
Some faults are usually fixable, and some mean the door has to go. For the ones that can be repaired, the method matters as much as the fault itself. Whether the right call is a Fire Door repair or replace decision depends on what's actually wrong, not on a blanket rule.
Not every fault on a survey report means the same thing. Some are quick, certified fixes. Others mean the leaf or frame is beyond saving.
Usually repairable on site: worn or perished intumescent strips, a damaged cold smoke seal, a loose or misaligned hinge, a closer that's stopped pulling the door shut properly, minor surface scuffs or small areas of localised damage to the leaf and gaps that have opened up around the edges or at the top.
Usually means replacement: a warped, cracked or delaminated leaf; structural damage to the frame itself; glazing that's been replaced with a non-fire-rated pane; a door that's been cut down, had holes drilled through it or otherwise altered outside what the manufacturer certified; and any door with no traceable fire rating at all, because there's no certified baseline a repair could bring it back to.
The honest answer for a lot of failed surveys sits in between: a door with several small remediable defects. Each one is individually fixable, but fixing five things on an old door can cost more and leave you with less certainty, than fitting a new certified one. We assess every door against its own certification and recommend whichever route that points to, not just whichever one we're able to do.
Excessive gaps between the door and the frame are the single biggest reason Fire Doors fail inspection. In the most recent published national survey (at the time of publish), the Fire Door Inspection Scheme (FDIS) found that 75% of more than 100,000 inspected doors failed to meet the required standard and excessive gaps were the leading cause, present in 77% of failures.
We won't give you a blanket gap measurement here. The acceptable tolerance depends on the specific door set, its certification and the perimeter seal fitted. A gap that's fine on one certified door can fail another. That's precisely why a competent survey against the door's own documentation matters more than a generic rule of thumb.
Whether a Fire Door repair holds up comes down to one thing: staying within the door's tested certification.
A Fire Door isn't tested as a single object. It's tested and certified as a complete assembly: the leaf, the frame, the intumescent strips, the smoke seals, the hinges, the closer and the glazing. All of them worked together exactly as they were when the test was carried out. That means a repair only stays certified if every replacement part comes from within that tested assembly or is a formally assessed substitute. Swap in a hinge that isn't rated for the job, pack a gap with the wrong material or fit glazing that wasn't part of the original test and the door's fire performance can no longer be assured, even though it still looks and closes like a Fire Door.
This is why a general joiner, however skilled with wood or a DIY fix over a weekend, can take a door outside its certified scope without anyone realising until the next inspection flags it. The work can be neat, solid and well-intentioned and still invalidate the rating, because like-for-like isn't a preference. It's the mechanism the certification runs on.
We're a division of Blake Contractors Ltd, which is BM TRADA Q-Mark certified for Fire Door installation and maintenance. That certification means repairs carried out under it follow the manufacturer's approved specification, using parts proven within the tested assembly, rather than whatever happens to fit on the day. One limit: a repair can restore a door to its own originally certified performance. It can't upgrade an uncertified or lower-rated door to a higher rating just by swapping in better components. If the leaf itself was never tested to that standard, no amount of good repair work changes that.
Intumescent strips and cold smoke seals are among the most commonly replaced Fire Door components and for good reason: they're consumable, exposed to daily wear and relatively quick to swap out when they're the right, certified type for your door. Getting the match wrong is the easy mistake to make.
A door that won't close fully or closes too slowly to seal before smoke or fire can pass, has failed its basic job regardless of how sound the leaf and frame are. Closer faults are usually straightforward to repair or replace, but the replacement closer has to match what the door was tested with. We've covered closers in more depth in their own post.
It's the same small set of faults we flagged as replacement-only above — a warped or delaminated leaf, no certification trail, unauthorised structural alterations — that rules out repair here too. In each of these cases, a damaged Fire Door needs replacement with a certified doorset; that's the only route that gets you back to a door you can actually evidence as compliant.
This section covers England only; Fire Safety law differs across the UK. For most commercial premises, the duty that applies is the Fire Safety Order 2005, Article 17, which requires the Responsible Person to keep Fire Doors, like all Fire Safety equipment, in efficient working order. It doesn't set a specific inspection frequency or a named standard.
A narrower duty applies if you're responsible for a multi-occupied residential building in England with a top storey above 11 metres. There, the Fire Safety (England) Regulations 2022, Regulation 10 requires the Responsible Person, usually the freeholder or managing agent, to check communal Fire Doors at least every three months and flat entrance doors at least every 12 months on a best-endeavours basis. Outside that specific band, Regulation 10 doesn't apply and the general Article 17 duty is what governs you.
BS 8214:2026, the current code of practice for fire-resisting and smoke control doors, recommends how design, installation and maintenance should be carried out for timber, metal and composite doors. It replaced the timber-only BS 8214:2016. A British Standard like this recommends good practice; it doesn't itself carry the force of law, but following it is a recognised way to help demonstrate you're meeting your legal duty.
This is an informational overview, not legal advice. Your own Fire Risk Assessment and a competent Fire Safety professional should confirm exactly what applies to your premises.
A repair that isn't recorded is, from a compliance standpoint, barely different from no repair at all. Whether you're working to Regulation 10's quarterly checks or the general Article 17 duty, you need to be able to show what was found, what was done and that it kept the door within its certified scope. That means a record of the fault, the repair carried out, the parts used and who did the work. If you're ever asked to evidence compliance, a dated repair record tied to a certified installer's documentation is what actually stands up.
If you're holding a failed survey and aren't sure whether a door needs a repair or a replacement, that's exactly the judgement call worth getting a second opinion on. The most direct next step is to get in touch and arrange a survey: our surveyor assesses the door against its own certification, then introduces you to the engineer who'll carry out the work, so you're dealing with the same familiar face throughout. Every engineer sent to you has had an Enhanced DBS check. And if your door needs work outside our BM TRADA Q-Mark scope, we'll say so rather than take the job anyway.
St. Joachim's Catholic Primary School came to us with exactly this kind of problem. As JA, Head Teacher, put it: "Thank you for responding to our plight from last week. You gave the issue a very robust response by working solidly for the last two days. I have used both doors now and they are just as we need them to be."
If you want to look into it yourself first, you can see our Fire Doors service, read our guide to what a Fire Door inspection actually involves or run some quick checks yourself using our 5 quick checks guide. If a door looks like it's being left open when it shouldn't be, our piece on whether an open Fire Door is dangerous is worth a read too. If you're not sure whether your premises genuinely need a specialist Fire Door company rather than a general contractor, we've set out the reasoning in this guide or you can download our compliant Fire Doors guide. We're an Essex-based, family-run firm, trading since 1979 and our specialist Fire Door team deals with exactly this decision every week, so whichever way your survey points, you're not the first to ask us.
Not every fault means a new door. Repairable faults typically include worn intumescent strips, a damaged cold smoke seal, a loose or misaligned hinge, a closer that's stopped pulling the door shut, minor surface scuffs and small areas of edge damage. Replacement is usually the only answer when the leaf is warped, cracked or delaminated, the frame itself is structurally damaged, glazing has been swapped for a non-fire-rated pane or the door has been cut, drilled or altered outside what the manufacturer certified. Doors with no traceable fire rating have nothing to repair back to. Some failed surveys fall in between - several small, individually fixable defects on one old door - where a proper assessment against the door's own certification, not a blanket rule, determines which route actually makes sense.
A Fire Door is tested and certified as a complete assembly - the leaf, frame, intumescent strips, smoke seals, hinges, closer and glazing all working together exactly as tested. A repair only stays certified if every replacement part comes from within that tested assembly or is a formally assessed substitute. Fitting a hinge that isn't rated for the job, packing a gap with the wrong material or using glazing that wasn't part of the original test means the door's fire performance can no longer be assured, even though it still looks and closes normally. A skilled general joiner or a careful DIY repair can take a door outside its certified scope without anyone realising until the next inspection flags it, because like-for-like isn't a quality preference - it's the mechanism the certification runs on.
Blake Fire & Security Systems is a division of Blake Contractors Ltd, which is BM TRADA Q-Mark certified for Fire Door installation and maintenance. That certification means repairs carried out under it follow the manufacturer's approved specification, using parts proven within the door's tested assembly, rather than whatever happens to fit on the day. It has a limit: a repair can restore a door to its own originally certified performance, but it can't upgrade an uncertified or lower-rated door to a higher rating just by fitting better components. If the leaf itself was never tested to that standard, no amount of good repair work changes that.
It depends on the building. For most commercial premises in England, the Fire Safety Order 2005, Article 17 requires the Responsible Person to keep Fire Doors, like all Fire Safety equipment, in efficient working order - but it doesn't set a specific inspection frequency or named standard. A narrower duty applies if you're responsible for a multi-occupied residential building in England with a top storey above 11 metres: the Fire Safety (England) Regulations 2022, Regulation 10 requires communal Fire Doors to be checked at least every three months and flat entrance doors at least every 12 months on a best-endeavours basis. Outside that specific band, Regulation 10 doesn't apply and the general Article 17 duty governs.
No. BS 8214:2026, the current code of practice for fire-resisting and smoke control doors, recommends how design, installation and maintenance should be carried out for timber, metal and composite doors - it replaced the timber-only BS 8214:2016. A British Standard like this doesn't itself carry the force of law. The actual legal duty comes from the Fire Safety Order 2005, Article 17 (the general duty to keep Fire Doors in efficient working order) and, for higher-risk residential buildings, Regulation 10 of the Fire Safety (England) Regulations 2022. Following BS 8214:2026 is a recognised way to help demonstrate you're meeting that legal duty, but it is guidance, not the requirement itself.
A repair that isn't recorded is, from a compliance standpoint, barely different from no repair at all. Whether you're working to Regulation 10's quarterly checks or the general Article 17 duty, you need to be able to show what was found, what was done and that the repair kept the door within its certified scope. That means keeping a record of the fault, the repair carried out, the parts used and who did the work. If you're ever asked to evidence compliance, a dated repair record tied to a certified installer's documentation is what actually stands up.